DEVELOPMENT CONTROL BOARD

22^ND NOVEMBER 2001

PRESENT:	Councillor June Williams (Chair)
Councillors: T.D. Bowen, I.W. Davies, J.J.J. Davies, D.C. Evans, H. John Evans, W.T. Evans, J. Gibbin, D.T. James, Ryan Jones, D.S. Neil, T. Theophilus, Sian Thomas(S), W. Dorrien Thomas and Joy S. Williams
The following officers were also in attendance: Mr. Stuart Owen - Development Control Manager Mrs. Marlene Miles-Richards - Senior Solicitor Mrs. Aldyth King - Assistant Committee Secretary
(s) - substitute
(Chamber, 3 Spilman Street, Carmarthen - 10.30 a.m. - 1.10 p.m.)

1. APOLOGIES

An apology for absence was received from Councillor Gwyneth Thomas.

2. DECLARATIONS OF PECUNIARY AND NON-PECUNIARY INTERESTS

There were no declarations of pecuniary interests.

The following non-pecuniary interests were made:-

Councillor H.J. Evans Councillor D.S. Neil	) )	Members of the Operations Board
Councillor J.J.J. Davies		E/03055
Councillor H.J. Evans		LL/00065

3. MINUTES

RESOLVED that the minutes of the meeting of the Board held on the 1^st November 2001 be approved as a correct record and signed. There were no matters arising.

4. E/02939 - ERECTION OF CENTRE FOR WELSH COBS (RE-SUBMISSION OF APPLICATION NO. E/02699 WITHDRAWN ON THE 17.7.01) AT LAND AT FORMER BARN AT FIELD ENC. 2276, RHOSFA ROAD, BRYNAMMAN, AMMANFORD

The Development Control Manager referred to the report especially the relevant planning history and informed Members that there was a typing error in that in June 1991 the conversion of the barn to a cottage was given full planning permission not refused as stated in the report.

As the conversion had progressed the deviation from the plans had resulted in officers calculating new build and Enforcement Notices had been issued, upheld non appeal, and currently waiting compliance. The three quarter built structure was outside the Development Limits and a number of proposals had been put forward to make use of the partially built building. This application had material differences including substantial earthworks to hide a curved roof which would be covered with earth and planted. This proposal addressed the question of visual amenity.

RESOLVED that consideration of the application be deferred in order that a site visit could be undertaken.

5. LL/00065 - RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT - 7 NO. DETACHED BUNGALOWS AT LLYS WARNER OFF WARNER PLACE, LLANELLI

Mr. Stuart Owen informed Members that an e-mail had been received from Councillor W.G. Thomas that morning that stated that although he declared a personal interest as his daughter, an objector, lived in 5 Warner Place, he expressed concern regarding the maintenance of a rear access which could be adversely affected. He also pointed out that there was a possibility that the stability of the ground could be questioned due to mining activity in the area in the past. Mr. Stuart Owen proposed to include in the consent a warning that the developer should take the appropriate precautions.

Mr. Stuart Owen reported that in 1993 planning permission was given for 12 dwellings on the site of which only four had been built. This new application had reduced the number left to 7. Representations had been received from residents of Warner Place who had over the time used part of the land as a rear access to their properties. Although the proposed development included a rear lane to the properties residents felt that it would be reduced in size and any garages would need to be set back within the rear gardens. Officers were of the opinion that this was a private matter and it was not a public right of way and it would not affect planning issues. The Officer's recommendation was for approval but it would be appropriate to include a note advising the applicant that there may be a legal challenge regarding the development which may result in the deletion of one plot.

The Chair then invited Mr. Woodford Rott on behalf of the objectors to speak.

Mr. Woodford Rott informed the Board that discussions had been held with the applicant's Architect, Mr. Brendan Minney, who had advised him that the developer was considering the deletion of one plot. There was no objection to the development, in principle, and the objectors were willing to discuss the matter further with the applicant.

The Chair invited Mr. Brendan Minney the applicant's Architect to speak.

Mr. Brendan Minney informed the Board that his client would like the application to be considered as submitted and allow the objectors to pursue the legal avenues open to them.

Mr. Stuart Owen reminded the Board that if the legal challenge was successful then the validity of the planning application may need to be revisited.

RESOLVED that the application be approved.

6. S/02876 - PROPOSED FOOTBALL FIELD AT PT. ENC. 8737, OFF PONTARDULAIS ROAD, LLANGENNECH, LLANELLI

Mr. Stuart Owen reminded Members that a site visit had been proposed in April 2001 but on arrival on site discussions between the residents and the applicant meant that the Board did not enter onto the site as there appeared to be an agreement that an alternative site would be more satisfactory. Since then all parties had sought other sites but none have become available. The applicant had now requested that as no alternative had become available that the original application be considered. Members were circulated with a plan of the proposed playing field. The Highways Authority were happy with the access subject to conditions. It was proposed to have landscaping between the car park and changing rooms and the dwellings with the pitch being sited on the other side of the changing rooms. Although the suggestion had been that the car park and changing rooms be positioned further away from the dwellings Mr. Stuart Owen felt that if the changing rooms were located close to the landscaping it would act as a buffer for any noise.

Mr. Stuart Owen reported that he had received a letter from the Local Member Councillor Mrs. Gwyneth Thomas who apologised for her absence but although recognised that there was a need for a football pitch in Llangennech, all attempts to find an alternative had failed. She had reservations regarding the chosen location, as there would be a loss of privacy and quiet to the street and on a highway safety ground as there could be on-street parking. Active negotiations were still continuing to find another location.

The Chair invited Mr. Eiddon Taylor on behalf of the residents to speak.

Mr. Taylor informed Members that he was representing over 30 residents who objected to the proposal. Although they recognised that the village needed a football pitch they objected to the location and layout on the grounds of road safety, litter, noise and security. Any footballs landing in the gardens could not only cause injury to people and children but also damage to properties. The erection of a fence at the bottom of the gardens did not appeal to residents as it would change the character of the area. Mr. Taylor also felt that the car parking area was inadequate and would result in cars being parked on the road which had been identified for traffic calming measures. The access road was opposite a children's playing area and with cars parked on the road then visibility for the house drives would be impaired. Mr. Taylor quoted an incident on a Saturday afternoon when the rugby team was playing at home, problems were encountered with cars being parked on the road even as far up as Pontardulais Road. He felt that the Director of Social Care and Housing supported the noise nuisance and loss of quality of life due to whistles, foul language etc. which would be clearly audible within the houses. He enquired whether a risk assessment had been carried out as to the effect it would have on the area. He felt that a change of use from grazing to a playing field that schools could use as well as a gathering place for young people, would have a detrimental effect on the quality of life of residents to the area.

Mr. Stuart Owen reported that a petition in support of the proposal had been received that morning which contained hundreds of signatures, although some were from outside Llangennech.

The Chair invited Mr. Barry Williams on behalf of the Football Club to speak. Mr. Williams pointed out that the Planning Officers were happy with the parking arrangements and felt that it would be safe. He also pointed out that a colliery used to be sited nearby and it was now proposed to locate a coal tip there. He did not feel that this application would affect the value of the houses.

Mr. Stuart Owen reported that fencing should not be placed at the rear of the gardens but in fact behind the goal line adjacent to the pitch in order to protect both the cars and the gardens. He reiterated the fact that the Highways Authority were satisfied with the proposals and they met the criteria laid down in both the Local and County Planning Policies.

RESOLVED that the application be approved.

7. W/04741 - 8' X 10' CONSERVATORY AT 5 TOWY VIEW RESIDENTIAL PARK, CAPEL DEWI ROAD, LLANGUNNOR

Mr. Stuart Owen informed Members that Carmarthen District Council had given consent in 1972 for a caravan site of 54 units with a few being static. The latest developer had proposed building chalets which were capable of being moved and were therefore considered as caravans even though they had a brick skirt. Nine units had been developed and the landscaping had been carried out to a high quality. This was an urban development in the Towy Valley, a Special Landscape Area, but there was nothing the Planning Authority could do. The proposal was for a permanent conservatory and therefore needed planning permission. Two detached garages had been erected and a decision would be made following the Board's decision on this application whether to instigate enforcement action.

RESOLVED that the application be refused.

8. TO/00009 - PROPOSED DETACHED DWELLING AND GARAGE AT LAND OFF GATE ROAD (ADJACENT 147), PENYGROES, LLANELLI

Mrs. Marlene Miles-Richards reported that a letter had been submitted that morning but it was too late to be photocopied and circulated. Having read the letter Marlene Miles-Richards was of the opinion that it contained matters that had been raised previously and circulated with the agenda.

Mr. Stuart Owen referred to the addendum wherein a letter had been submitted by the Lash Valley Protection Group and Members were given time to read it. Mr. Stuart Owen confirmed that he had received a letter from the National Assembly which referred to a request to call in two applications in the area. The National Assembly did not feel that the applications warranted calling it in and referred them back to the Board for consideration.

This was a single plot within Development Limits and the planning history showed a clear presumption for development. The Community Council and the Lash Valley Protection Group had expressed concern regarding sewers in the area. The Environment Agency recognised that there was a problem with the Blaenau/Penygroes sewer pollution for a number of years but had no objection to a single dwelling to connect at separate points. As the Environment Agency was the responsible body, the Authority had to take their views and the application could not be refused on sewerage problems. Councillor Sian Thomas reported that although she was not the Local Member the Pumping Station for the area was in her area. She had been called out there several times due to problems. She reminded Members that planning permission had been given before in the same area on the same site and questioned how many there would need to be built before it was designated as a site. Mr. Stuart Owen reminded Members that if the application was refused contrary to Environment Agency recommendations then we could not justify the refusal on a technical basis and the Authority could be liable to costs if any subsequent appeal.

RESOLVED that the application be approved.

9. TO/00063 - TRAINING CENTRE DEVELOPMENT COMPRISING: DEMOLITION OF EXISTING REDUNDANT FARM BUILDINGS AND ERECTION OF NEW TEACHING AND ADMINISTRATION BUILDING AND RESIDENTIAL BUILDING (25 STUDENTS STUDY BEDROOMS AND 1 NO. 2 BED WARDENS FLAT), PLUS NEW CALF SHED AND ASSOCIATED EXTERNAL WORKS AT GELLI AUR FARM, GELLI AUR, LLANDEILO

RESOLVED that the application be approved.

10. AMAN AREA - DETERMINATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS

RESOLVED:-

10.1. that the following planning applications be granted subject to the conditions detailed within the report of the Head of Planning and/or reported at the meeting:-

E/02925	Demolition of existing dwelling. Construction of new house and garage at 42 Highfield Road, Twyn, Garnant, Ammanford.
(Councillor Kevin Madge expressed concern at the siting of the caravan.)
E/02976	Proposed double garage with hobby and play rooms over to replace 4 no. dilapidated single garages at 172 Cwmamman Road, Garnant, Ammanford.
(The applicant had withdrawn the proposals to put two windows in the roof.)
E/03019	Application for 8 single storey units (re-submission of Application No. E/02674 refused on 9.8.01) at Parc Glan Yr Afon (Tan-Y-Gelli), Glanamman, Ammanford.
Councillor Colin Evans expressed concern at the access road via Folland Road which was inadequate and had no footways or road lighting. He was also concerned that consideration was being given to building new area school off Folland Road. Councillor Evans also expressed concern that the Environment Agency had made no comment following their preparation of the Definitive Map which showed that Tan-Y-Gelli would be part of a flood plain. Mr. Stuart Owen advised that it was accepted that the site was allocated for development. If the Environment Agency decided that it was a change of circumstance it would be up to them to fight it.
E/03036	1 House at Plot 2 opposite Brynawelon, Saron Road, Saron, Ammanford.
S/02926	4 No. fishing lakes with disabled access - fence to surround existing Golf Driving Range at Tycroes Golf Range, Tycroes, Ammanford.
AM/00013	1 House at Plot 1 opposite Brynawelon, Saron Road, Saron, Ammanford.
AM/00039	Re-submission of Application No. E/02900 (Approved 30.8.01) - construction of 1 no. detached dwelling - for Section 106 Agreement re: drainage at Plot adj. To 19 Church Street, Llandybie, Ammanford.
AM/00041	Planning consent for road and plot layout for 40 dwellings - renewal of S/00213 at land at Penygarn Road, Tycroes.
Mr. Stuart Owen informed Members that it was hoped that the embargo on the Amman trunk sewer could be lifted within 3 to 4 months.

10.2. that the following planning application be refused for the reasons detailed within the report of the Head of Planning and/or reported at the meeting:-

E/02818

To change from office to taxi office (re-submission of Application No. E/02462 refused on 11.1.01) at 22 Wind Street, Ammanford.

10.3. that the Board note that no grants from the National Assembly could be used to restore the site rather than for extracting the coal:-

M4	Gilfach Iago Site (Minerals File).

11. GWENDRAETH AREA - DETERMINATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS

RESOLVED:-

11.1. that the following planning applications be granted subject to the conditions detailed within the report of the Head of Planning and/or reported at the meeting:-

GW/00010	One residential dwelling at plot and land adjoining 51 Penygroes Road, Caer Bryn, Ammanford.
GW/00060	Improvements to existing access to Llannon Sewage Treatment Works at Cwm Hywel, Llannon, Llanelli.
GW/00067	Single storey conservatory at Lynwood, Ferryside.

11.2. that the following applications be refused for the reasons detailed within the report of the Head of Planning and/or reported at the meeting:

GW/00079	Residential development at field adjacent to Gors Road, Tumble, Llanelli.
GW/00084	House and garage at Dyffryn Araul, Bethesda Road, Tumble, Llanelli.
W/04758	Change of use of barn to granny annexe at Elfane, Mynyddcerrig, Llanelli.

12. LLANELLI AREA - DETERMINATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS

RESOLVED:-

12.1. that the following planning applications be granted subject to the conditions detailed within the report of the Head of Planning and/or reported at the meeting:-

LL/00026	Single storey extension to rear of existing dwelling to provide disabled shower/wc facilities at 57 Albert Street, Llanelli.
LL/00043	Change of use from shop and associated stores to living quarters at 5 Randell Square, Pembrey.
S/03298	Construction of 16 dwellings - 14 detached houses and 2 detached bungalows. This application being Phase II of a larger development at land off Lon y Maes, Pemberton Park, Llanelli.
S/03339	2 storey standard template extension to hospital for proposed elderly services EMI unit/day hospital and administrative facility at lower level with elderly rehabilitation services on upper floor level with 145 extra parking spaces at Prince Philip Hospital, Bryngwynmawr, Dafen, Llanelli.
S/03361	Erection of kitchen/bathroom single storey extension at 5 School Road, Morfa, Llanelli.

12.2. that the following applications be refused for the reasons detailed within the report of the Head of Planning and/or reported at the meeting:-

LL/00080	Proposed demolition of existing commercial premises and construction of 3 bedroom detached dormer bungalow at Pencoed Garage, Pencoed Road, Burry Port, Llanelli.
S/03233	Extension to existing nursing home to provide 2 no. bedrooms and a physiotherapy room at Ty Mair Nursing Home, 12 Penygaer Cottages, Felinfoel, Llanelli.

12.3. that the following application be deferred in order that a site visit could be undertaken:-

LL/00077

One dwelling at plot being part of the rear garden of Bodowen, The Links, Pembrey, Llanelli.

13. TAF MYRDDIN AREA - DETERMINATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS

RESOLVED:-

13.1. that the following planning applications be granted subject to the conditions detailed within the report of the Head of Planning and/or reported at the meeting:-

W/04608	Construction of stable and store building at Afon Lodge, Parciau Bach, St. Clears, Carmarthen.
W/04682	Proposed swimming pool, dormitory and shower extensions at Morfa Bay Outdoor Centre, Pendine, Carmarthen.
W/04709	Renewal of W/02056 at land at Cynwyl Elfed.
That the Outline Planning permission be granted for 1 year only.
W/04751	To convert a 4 bedroom house (internally) to a 2 bedroom and a 1 bedroom maisonette at 18 St. Catherine Street, Carmarthen.
W/04755	Extension of yard and parking area at Stag Mill Garage, Alltwalis Road, Carmarthen.
W/04760	Extension to existing planning permission reference W/04459 granted 9.8.01, to provide accommodation for new ambulance service contact centre and possible future contact centre at Dyfed-Powys Police, Police Headquarters, Llangunnor.
TM/00021	Housing development 2 houses, 4 bungalows for phase 1 development at land fronting Trevaughan Road, Carmarthen.
TM/00022	Construction of warehouse, showroom and trade counter at Plot 31A, Cillefwr Industrial Estate, Johnstown, Carmarthen.
TM/00023	Attached garage at 32 Dol Y Dderwen, Llangain, Carmarthen.
TM/00050	Extension and replacing of felt flat roof with slated sloping roof at Coedmor, The Green, Llansteffan.

13.2. that the following application be deferred in order that the Local Member, the Chair and Officers meet on site to discuss concerns regarding the access:-

TM/00034

Change of use from coal merchants yard to macadam surfacing contractors' depot at site North of Cillefwr Road West, Cillefwr Industrial Estate, Johnstown, Carmarthen.

13.3. that the following planning applications be refused for the reasons detailed within the report of the Head of Planning and/or reported at the meeting:-

W/04120	Construction of agricultural buildings and slurry lagoon at Big House Farm, Pendine, St. Clears.
W/04762	Four detached private dwellings at Paddock adjacent to Parc Y Bryn, Springfield Road, Carmarthen.
TM/00004	Siting of 2 no. dwellings for residential use at land formerly part of Blaencwm Farm, Trawsmawr, Carmarthen.
TM/00052	Seasonal use of land for the siting of 25 no. trailer caravans with towing vehicles at The Savoy Country Inn, Tenby Road, St. Clears, Carmarthenshire.

13.4. that the following application be approved on the amended recommendation of the Head of Planning:-

W/04689

Portal framed building replacing demolished tin sheds at Crosshands House, Henllan Amgoed, Whitland.

13.5. that the following application be refused on the amended recommendation of the Head of Planning:-

TM/00072

Siting of a bungalow at Stoneleigh, 3 Bronwydd Road, Carmarthen.

14. TEIFI AREA - DETERMINATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS

RESOLVED:-

14.1. that the following planning applications be granted subject to the conditions detailed within the report of the Head of Planning and/or reported at the meeting:-

W/04201	Conversion and extension of existing barn into 1 no. residential dwelling at Maestyle Farm, Esgerdawe, Llandeilo.
W/04753	Siting of two dwellings at land at Pentop, Llanllwni.
W/04757	New dwelling and garage at land opposite 15 New Road, Newcastle Emlyn.
TE/00121	Discharge agricultural restriction at Blaenpant, Pencarreg, Llanybydder, Carmarthenshire.
Officers be given plenary powers to approve the application if no objections were received at the end of the consultation period.

14.2. that the following applications be refused for the reasons detailed within the report of the Head of Planning and/or reported at the meeting:-

W/04133	Residential caravan at Glyncoch Uchaf, Bancyffordd, Llandysul.
TE/00005	Certificate for Lawful Use for an existing use at storage of timber at Next to Waunmarlog, Station Road, Newcastle Emlyn.

15. TYWI AREA - DETERMINATION OF PLANNING APPLICATIONS

RESOLVED:-

15.1. that the following planning applications be granted subject to the conditions detailed within the report of the Head of Planning and/or reported at the meeting:-

E/02887	Provision of amenity pond to form raised bunds/access roads - surplus material to be used in part of flood bunds for Llandovery Flood Alleviation project at School Playing Fields, Llandovery College, Queensway, Llandovery, Carmarthenshire.
E/02995	Proposed double garage with first floor storage area at Caebach Villa, Penybanc, Llandeilo, Carmarthenshire.
E/03021	Removal of Condition 5 of Outline Planning Consent P6/16/5481/79 (and Condition 2 of Reserved Matters Consent P6/16/6934/81) and Condition 15 of Outline Consent P6/16/5481/79 which removes the agricultural tie on the property at "Brynhaelog", Salem, Llandeilo.
E/03033	Single storey extension to existing house and single storey extension to outbuilding at "Cartref", Rhandirmwyn, Llandovery, Carmarthenshire.
E/03042	Discharge of Section 106 (52) Agreement - on Application P6/16/5481/79 approved on 3.4.80 for a bungalow and garage at Brynhaelog, Salem, Llandeilo.
TO/00056	20m lattice tower with 3 no. antennae and cabin within 12 x 8m compound with power supply and telecommunication connection at Pantyresgair Yard, Talley, Llandeilo, Carmarthenshire.
Councillor J.J.J. Davies moved refusal of the application.
TO/00058	Stable block, tack room and workshop at field no. 5735 land adj to Bryngwyn Farm, Salem, Llandeilo.

15.2. that the following application be deferred in order that a site visit could be undertaken:-

E/03055

Construction of a single dwelling at land adjacent to former Church Hall, Maerdy, Taliaris, Llandeilo.

16. INFORMATION REPORT

The Board received the report of the Head of Planning on the above matter.

RESOLVED:-

16.1. that the approval of the following planning applications by the Head of Planning and his delegated authority be noted:-

E/02988	To retain use as café/take-away/restaurant at 3 Hall Street, Ammanford.
E/02991	Bedroom and living room extension at 90 Dyffryn Road, Saron, Ammanford.
E/03017	One house and five bungalows at field no. 2131 off Nant Y Ci Road, Saron, Ammanford.
E/03025	Proposed side/rear extension at 4 Penpound Lane, Llandybie, Ammanford.
E/03053	Demolition of building (prior notification) at former Tennis Pavilion, Ammanford Park, Ammanford.
E/02865	Kitchen/bathroom extension at 2 North Bank, Llandeilo.
E/02923	Carrying out works to the property under the Llandovery Townscape Heritage Initiative including upgrade to the principal elevations to agreed historical detail and brining back into use vacant first and second floors to create bed and breakfast facilities associated with current ground floor which is also refurbished at Dyfri Bakery, 12 Kings Road, Llandovery.
E/02971	Conversion of two barns to dwelling at two barns at Graig Beynon, Llanwrda, Carmarthenshire.
E/02987	Implement shed at Parc Y Rhos, Llansawel, Llandeilo.
E/02996	Proposed conversion of and extension to existing storage barn at barn adj to Cwm Ceiliog Farm, Taliaris, Llandeilo.
E/02999	Paved patio with low wall surround at Llandovery Heritage Centre, Ty Llwyd, Kings Road, Llandovery.
E/03000	Rear 2 storey extension to existing dwelling at Ty Crug, Pontynyswen, Carmarthenshire.
E/03007	New conservatory at Homelands, 23 Llys Y Ferin, Nantgaredig, Carmarthen.
E/03030	Proposed detached dwelling and attached garage (amendment to Application No. E/02894 approved on 30.8.01) at land off 2 Parc Henri Villas, Dryslwyn, Carmarthen.
E/03041	Conversion of out-houses to three bedroomed cottage (renewal of E/00181 approved on 10.10.96) at "Plas Y Dderwen", 17 High Street, Llandovery.
E/03056	Dutch barn and side barns at Llwynbwch, Llansadwrn, Llanwrda.
TO/00008	Lean-to to hayshed - general purpose and implements at Ashfield Farm, Llangadog.
TP/00054	Sheep housing shed at Dolaugwynion Farm, Llandovery.
E/03037	Erect extension to lounge, en-suite and dressing area, kitchen and utilities at "Pennant", Blaenau, Llandybie, Ammanford.
GW/00011	Dismantle existing conservatory. Erection of new rear extension. Re-assemble conservatory in revised location at Gwarcoed, Thornhill Road, Cwmgwili, Cross Hands, Llanelli.
S/03305	1 x wall mounted advertising display unit at Furnace News, 1 Luton Terrace, New Road, Llanelli.
S/03307	1 x double sided free standing advertising display unit at Bridge Stores and service station, Bridge Street, Llangennech, Llanelli.
S/03308	1 x single sided free standing advertising display unit at 31 Llwynhendy Road, Llwynhendy, Llanelli.
S/03317	1 no. residential house at Plot 3, Caeffynnon, Ferry Road, Kidwelly.
S/03324	Domestic garage at 17 Felinfoel Road, Llanelli.
S/03328	Proposed extension to existing premises at Stepney Hotel, Park Street, Llanelli.
S/03330	Two storey extension (kitchen and bedroom) at 18 Banc Pendre, Kidwelly.
S/03332	Demolish existing kitchen/bathroom single storey extension and replace with new single storey extension (pitched roof, cavity walls) comprising kitchen, bathroom and living room at 14 Delabeche Street, Llanelli.
S/03335	Installation of proposed 24 hour ATM cashpoint, Co-Op Store, 68 Station Road, Burry Port.
S/03336	ATM surround and projecting sign at Co-Op Store, 68 Station Road, Burry Port.
S/03342	Erection of single storey kitchen, utility and shower room extension at 16 Penyrheol Drive, Llanelli.
S/03345	White uPVC conservatory at 2 Bont Cottages, Trimsaran Road, Kidwelly.
S/03349	Installation of proposed 24 hour ATM cashpoint at Co-Op Supermarket, Llandeilo Road, Cross Hands, Llanelli.
S/03350	Illuminated ATM surround only at Co-Op Supermarket, Llandeilo Road, Cross Hands, Llanelli.
S/03352	Lean-to conservatory at 4 Albert Street, Llanelli.
S/03356	Proposed rear and side extension at 20 Tyrfran Avenue, Llanelli.
S/03357	Fascia sign, projecting sign, menu sign at Co-Op Store, 68 Station Road, Burry Port.
S/03358	3 no. fascia signs at Mallard House, 1 Upper Park Street, Llanelli.
S/03362	2 freestanding signs attached to existing light columns on front of restaurant at 4A Vaughan Street, Llanelli.
S/03365	1 no. two storey dwelling with integral garage at Plot 3, Beech Grove, Pwll, Llanelli.
W/04590	Agricultural outbuilding for housing of livestock at Clunderwen Farm, Clunderwen, Carmarthenshire.
W/04636	Outside painting required main walls:- Terracotta Reveals:- Cream Door:- Persian Blue at Drovers arms, 106 Lammas Street, Carmarthen.
W/04641	Overhead electric line at Broadlay, Ferryside, Carmarthen.
W/04675	Part ground floor and first floor rear additions at 1 Plas Y Berth, Bancyfelin, Carmarthen.
W/04686	Detached bungalow and garage at Plots 24 and 26, Clos Y Dderwen, Crosshands Road, Gorslas.
W/04687	Change of use of agricultural storage buildings to stables at Felin Bach, Bronwydd, Carmarthen.
W/04698	Change of use from Funeral Director's Chapel of Rest to a 24 hour taxi waiting room and booking office at formerly known as D. Jones, Funeral Directors, Station Approach, Carmarthen.
W/04701	Extension to dwellings at Maesycoed, St. Clears.
W/04710	Advertisement sign at Carmarthen and Pumsaint Farmers Limited, Pensarn Store, Pensarn Roundabout, Pensarn, Carmarthen.
W/04713	One double sided freestanding advertising display unit at Today's Village Store and P.O., Drefach, Llanelli.
W/04714	3 bed bungalow and double garage at Plot adjacent to Morawel, Meinciau Mawr Road, Meinciau, Llanelli.
W/04721	Advertisement sign at Johnstown Filling Station, St. Clears Road, Johnstown.
W/04722	Advertisement sign at Tenby Road Filling Station, Llysonnen Road, Carmarthen.
W/04723	Advertisement sign at Gorslas Village Store, The Square, Gorslas, Llanelli.
W/04730	Extension to provide restaurant area at The Queen Victoria Inn, Heol-y-Meinciau, Pontyates, Llanelli.
W/04734	Advertisement sign at Walter Lloyd and Son Pharmacy, 12 Lammas Street, Carmarthen.
W/04736	Domestic extension at Penwern, Saron, Carmarthenshire.
W/04737	Agricultural storage barn at High View, Cynwyl Elfed, Carmarthen.
W/04742	Renovation extension and new garage at application site at Glyncoch, Maesycrugian, Pencader.
W/04746	Erect of PVCU conservatory to front of property at 21 Manor Crescent, Llanllwch.
TM/00036	Extension to bedroom at Penrhiw Crynfryn, Blaenycoed Road, Carmarthen.

17. BUILDING REGULATIONS AND NOTICES

The Board received and noted the written report of the Head of Planning and the Building Regulation Notices received by the Authority together with approvals/refusals issued.

18. CODE OF CONDUCT FOR COUNCILLORS AND OFFICERS ON PLANNING MATTERS

The Development Control Manager reported that he had attended the Standards Committee on the 25^th October with the Vice-Chair when it had been resolved to add an additional two paragraphs to the Code of Conduct to reflect Members concern regarding attendance at Community Council meetings, and the role of Members substituting at Development Control Board and Special Planning Committees. These additions had now been incorporated into the Code of Conduct and had been circulated with the Agenda for further comments.

RESOLVED that the report be noted.

19. EXCLUSION OF THE PRESS

RESOLVED that pursuant to Section 100A(4) of the Local Government Act 1972 the public be excluded from the meeting for consideration of the following item as it involved the disclosure of exempt information as defined within the description set out in Paragraph 13 of Part 1 of Schedule 12A to the Act, namely information which if disclosed to the public would reveal that the Authority proposed (a) to give under any enactment a Notice under or by virtue of which requirements are imposed upon a person or (b) to make an Order or Direction under any enactment.

20. ENFORCEMENT REPORT

Members received and noted the report of the Head of Planning on planning enforcement and monitoring identified in the County.